Call Now • 716-260-1043


Buffalo NY Pizza | Amherst NY Pizza

One of Buffalo NY's Unique Pizza Restaurants. My Tomato Pie is famous for their fried green tomatoes. Offering Amherst NY with great Pizza. We are located right on Niagara Falls Blvd and East Robinson.

The menu also includes homemade soups, salad dressings, delicious gourmet pizzas, pastas and delicious sandwiches served on homemade foccacia bread.Their homemade desserts include Key lime and peanut butter pies. This child-friendly restaurant also serves a kiddie menu and beer and wine for Mom and Dad. Read More

Featured Menu Items

  • Spaghetti tossed in Mama Rose's Restaurant homemade tomato sauce and topped with melted Mozzarella.
    9.99$
  • Meatballs, tomato sauce, ricotta cheese, hot banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese. Sm or Lg.
    14.99$
    19.99$
  • Smoked turkey breast, slived ham, egg, tomato, bacon, and crumbled bleu cheese over mixed greens.
    9.99$
  • Chicken fingers, bleu cheese, tomatoes, onions, franks hot sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
    10.59$
  • Signature tomato cream soup with Asiago cheese and homemade croutons.
    4.59$
  • House Salad, Pastas Salad, Turkey Focaccia, Ham Focaccia, Tuna Melt Focaccia, Cookie Tray, and 2-liters.
    11.50$ per person
  • Roasted turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, and melted cheddar jack cheese on focaccia bread w/ cranberry mayonnaise.
    9.59$
  • Our classic Key Lime Pie.
    6$
  • Grilled chicken breast, sautéed broccoli, Portobello mushrooms in a Cajun cream sauce with Gemelli pasta.
    14.99$
  • 1/2 lb. Sirloin & Brisket w/ Amer. cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, sauce. Side: pasta salad, chips, or apple.
    9.99$
  • 1/2 lb. Sirloin & Brisket w/ Bleu cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and red onion. Side: of pasta salad, chips, or apple.
    10.99$

Share My Tomato Pie With Your Friends!